Can You Create A Market For Privacy? Would Anyone Care If You Did?
Date : 02 29 2008 Category : Business
David writes in to point us to Jim Manzi's guest post at Andrew Sullivan's Daily Dish suggesting that a way to deal with privacy issues is to create a market for private info. This is not a new idea, though it's not clear if Manzi knows about those who have tried it before. Root Markets has been trying to do this for years without getting that much traction. Manzi's idea is that right now people are lax with transaction data because they really have no choice: "When the choices are (1) opt out of modern life, or (2) implicitly surrender all of this info, pretty much everybody picks door #2." His description of the solution, however, should immediately ring some bells on an analogy that shows why his plan will almost certainly never work:
"But what if I had the practical ability to charge commercial entities for access to or use of information of this sort? It would, first, go from a free good to a scarcer resource, and second, I could protect those parts of my transaction history that I feel to be most sensitive. In effect, we need a functioning market into which I can sell my transaction history."
Yes, he's basically saying that we should take an infinite resource (data about our transactions) and forcibly create artificial scarcity, and then create a market around that artificial scarcity. It sounds nice in theory, but given how just about every market that's based on artificial scarcity is disintegrating as we speak, it seems unlikely to get very far. If there's one lesson that we've learned from watching the entertainment industry implode over the last decade, it should be that artificial scarcity doesn't last. Basing a business model on artificial scarcity is incredibly risky.
Given how little attention Root Markets has received from users, Manzi may not be correct in estimating where consumers' feelings lie on this matter. As they've shown time and time again, it's not that people want to keep their transaction data private and just don't have the means to do so -- it's that very few really seem to care at all.
Permalink | Comments | Email This Story

Given how little attention Root Markets has received from users, Manzi may not be correct in estimating where consumers' feelings lie on this matter. As they've shown time and time again, it's not that people want to keep their transaction data private and just don't have the means to do so -- it's that very few really seem to care at all.
Permalink | Comments | Email This Story